Headlines
State of Economy-VI: Booster investment dosage needed to fire-up slacking consumption
Mumbai, May 20
A booster dose of government and private sector spending along with cheaper rates of finance is required to kick-start India's consumption-driven demand, industry observers opined.
To put it simply, the overall economic growth is expected to decline on the back of slacking consumption due to farm distress, global headwinds and stagnant wages. These have cumulatively hampered sales, thereby restricting production and as a result stalled job creation.
Furthermore, the slowdown has become evident in sectors such as automobile, FMCG and aviation.
"Consumption in India has slowed due to several factors, including low rural demand reflected in low prices that is a by-product of low rural wage growth and significantly low level of global food prices for a protracted period keeping a lid on MSP," said Soumya Kanti Ghosh, Group Chief Economic Adviser, SBI.
"Besides, private investments are not forthcoming, so public investment should continue to keep pace, which looks difficult given the current fiscal constraints. Therefore monetary policy should do the heavy lifting as fiscal policy is constrained."
Latest economic indicators, including Index of Eight Core Industries, Index of Industrial Production and inflation gauges have shown a worsening trend which industry observers fear will continue.
A case in point is the automobile off-take data. In April, car sales which indicate urban and semi-urban demand declined 19.93 per cent to 160,279 units.
In the commercial vehicle segment, which is the key indicator of economic activity, domestic sales went down by 5.98 per cent to 68,680 units last month.
Similarly, overall sales of two-wheelers, which include scooters, motorcycles and mopeds, edged lower by 16.36 per cent to 1,638,388 units.
Consequently, the country's factory output has also slipped. In March, it declined to over a 20-month low, as the output rate of the manufacturing sector fell (-)0.4 per cent from a year-on-year (YoY) rise of 5.7 per cent.
Recently, State Bank of India's Economic Research Department in a report said: "In Q4FY19, of 384 companies more than 330 companies exhibited negative growth in mid-line and bottom-line."
"Perhaps, significantly depressed rural prices are disturbing rural income and weak demand is affecting the FMCG sector."
Even the external environment is not conducive enough to revive growth through exports as Crude oil is already hovering around $72 per barrel and trade tensions continue to simmer.
"Demand is likely to remain sluggish in the near term. The global growth is likely to remain patchy, implying weaker exports demand and weaker manufacturing production," said Madhavi Arora, Lead Economist, Edelweiss Securities
"Besides, weaker domestic demand will also weigh on industrial production."
On the reforms front, India Ratings and Research's Chief Economist and Senior Director Public Finance Devendra Kumar Pant said: "Structural issues related to household savings and investments need to be sorted out. The basically problem is that wage growth has stagnated and in some cases, it is declining."
"In the short-term monetary policy easing and active transmission from banks might boost sentiments, but for the long-term resolving structural issues related to household savings and investments is the key."
In addition, a recent report published earlier this month by Kotak Institutional Equities Research quoted certain references made by FMCG companies in their 3QFY19 earnings calls, where the requirement of 'stimulus' was hinted.
"... We see a major shift in tone (for the worse) on short-term demand narrative in the management commentaries of the companies that have reported thus far. When generally-measured management like HUVR's uses the term 'recession' in its comments in the post-results presser, it generally isn't a one-quarter blip," the report said.
To put it simply, the overall economic growth is expected to decline on the back of slacking consumption due to farm distress, global headwinds and stagnant wages. These have cumulatively hampered sales, thereby restricting production and as a result stalled job creation.
Furthermore, the slowdown has become evident in sectors such as automobile, FMCG and aviation.
"Consumption in India has slowed due to several factors, including low rural demand reflected in low prices that is a by-product of low rural wage growth and significantly low level of global food prices for a protracted period keeping a lid on MSP," said Soumya Kanti Ghosh, Group Chief Economic Adviser, SBI.
"Besides, private investments are not forthcoming, so public investment should continue to keep pace, which looks difficult given the current fiscal constraints. Therefore monetary policy should do the heavy lifting as fiscal policy is constrained."
Latest economic indicators, including Index of Eight Core Industries, Index of Industrial Production and inflation gauges have shown a worsening trend which industry observers fear will continue.
A case in point is the automobile off-take data. In April, car sales which indicate urban and semi-urban demand declined 19.93 per cent to 160,279 units.
In the commercial vehicle segment, which is the key indicator of economic activity, domestic sales went down by 5.98 per cent to 68,680 units last month.
Similarly, overall sales of two-wheelers, which include scooters, motorcycles and mopeds, edged lower by 16.36 per cent to 1,638,388 units.
Consequently, the country's factory output has also slipped. In March, it declined to over a 20-month low, as the output rate of the manufacturing sector fell (-)0.4 per cent from a year-on-year (YoY) rise of 5.7 per cent.
Recently, State Bank of India's Economic Research Department in a report said: "In Q4FY19, of 384 companies more than 330 companies exhibited negative growth in mid-line and bottom-line."
"Perhaps, significantly depressed rural prices are disturbing rural income and weak demand is affecting the FMCG sector."
Even the external environment is not conducive enough to revive growth through exports as Crude oil is already hovering around $72 per barrel and trade tensions continue to simmer.
"Demand is likely to remain sluggish in the near term. The global growth is likely to remain patchy, implying weaker exports demand and weaker manufacturing production," said Madhavi Arora, Lead Economist, Edelweiss Securities
"Besides, weaker domestic demand will also weigh on industrial production."
On the reforms front, India Ratings and Research's Chief Economist and Senior Director Public Finance Devendra Kumar Pant said: "Structural issues related to household savings and investments need to be sorted out. The basically problem is that wage growth has stagnated and in some cases, it is declining."
"In the short-term monetary policy easing and active transmission from banks might boost sentiments, but for the long-term resolving structural issues related to household savings and investments is the key."
In addition, a recent report published earlier this month by Kotak Institutional Equities Research quoted certain references made by FMCG companies in their 3QFY19 earnings calls, where the requirement of 'stimulus' was hinted.
"... We see a major shift in tone (for the worse) on short-term demand narrative in the management commentaries of the companies that have reported thus far. When generally-measured management like HUVR's uses the term 'recession' in its comments in the post-results presser, it generally isn't a one-quarter blip," the report said.

5 hours ago
Australian study unlocks secrets of ancient life through fossil faeces

5 hours ago
Nepal: Interim PM Karki has to rebuild public trust in governance

5 hours ago
Afghan senior official slams Trump's remarks on Bagram airbase

5 hours ago
Tech giants urge H-1B holders to stay in US after Trump's visa overhaul, ask those abroad to return to US

5 hours ago
CoHNA celebrates end of DOJ investigation on BAPS temple

5 hours ago
Not only US, several countries are restricting entry

5 hours ago
US decision on H-1B visa fee hike likely to have humanitarian consequences: Govt

5 hours ago
US experts warn Trump administration against undermining relationship with India: Report

8 hours ago
Our foreign policy, diplomacy have completely failed: Imran Masood slams govt after Prez Trump’s H-1B visa fee hike

8 hours ago
Congress criticises US President Trump, Centre's policies over H-1B visa fee hike

9 hours ago
Miami City Commission will open with hymns from Rig-Veda, Upanishads, Bhagavad-Gita

9 hours ago
The great American dream may now be too expensive to achieve

11 hours ago
Netizens react to Deepika Padukone's cryptic note: 'People matter more than success'