Technology
'Fake news' not easy to spot on Facebook: Study
New York, Nov 6
You can't trust yourself to discern what's true and what's not when you're on Facebook as researchers have found that 'Fake news' is not easy to spot on the social networking site.
"We all believe that we are better than the average person at detecting fake news, but that's simply not possible," said study lead author Patricia Moravec, Assistant Professor at the University of Texas in the US.
"The environment of social media and our own biases make us all much worse than we think," Moravec added.
For the study, published in the journal Management Information Systems Quarterly, the researchers worked with 80 social media-proficient undergraduate students who first answered 10 questions about their own political beliefs.
Each participant was then fitted with an EEG headset.
The students were asked to read 50 political news headlines presented as they would appear in a Facebook feed and assess their credibility.
Forty of the headlines were evenly divided between true and false, with 10 headlines that were clearly true included as controls: 'Trump Signs New Executive Order on Immigration' (clearly true), 'Nominee to Lead EPA Testifies He'll Enforce Environmental Laws' (true), 'Russian Spies Present at Trump's Inauguration -- Seated on Inauguration Platform' (false).
The researchers randomly assigned fake news flags among the 40 non-control headlines to see what effect they would have on the participants' responses.
In late 2016, Facebook incorporated fact-checking into its platform and began flagging certain news articles by noting that an article was 'disputed by third-party fact checkers.'
The students rated each headline's believability, credibility and truthfulness.
As they worked through the exercise, the participants spent more time and showed significantly more activity in their frontal cortices -- the brain area associated with arousal, memory access and consciousness -- when headlines supported their beliefs but were flagged as false.
These reactions of discomfort indicated cognitive dissonance when headlines supporting their beliefs were marked as untrue.
But this dissonance was not enough to make participants change their minds. They overwhelmingly said that headlines conforming with their pre-existing beliefs were true, regardless of whether they were flagged as potentially fake.
The flag did not change their initial response to the headline, even if it did make them pause a moment longer and study it a bit more carefully.
Political affiliation made no difference in their ability to determine what was true or false.
The experiment showed that social media users are highly subject to confirmation bias, the unintentional tendency to gravitate toward and process information that is consistent with existing beliefs, she said.
This can result in decision-making that ignores information that is inconsistent with those beliefs.
"We all believe that we are better than the average person at detecting fake news, but that's simply not possible," said study lead author Patricia Moravec, Assistant Professor at the University of Texas in the US.
"The environment of social media and our own biases make us all much worse than we think," Moravec added.
For the study, published in the journal Management Information Systems Quarterly, the researchers worked with 80 social media-proficient undergraduate students who first answered 10 questions about their own political beliefs.
Each participant was then fitted with an EEG headset.
The students were asked to read 50 political news headlines presented as they would appear in a Facebook feed and assess their credibility.
Forty of the headlines were evenly divided between true and false, with 10 headlines that were clearly true included as controls: 'Trump Signs New Executive Order on Immigration' (clearly true), 'Nominee to Lead EPA Testifies He'll Enforce Environmental Laws' (true), 'Russian Spies Present at Trump's Inauguration -- Seated on Inauguration Platform' (false).
The researchers randomly assigned fake news flags among the 40 non-control headlines to see what effect they would have on the participants' responses.
In late 2016, Facebook incorporated fact-checking into its platform and began flagging certain news articles by noting that an article was 'disputed by third-party fact checkers.'
The students rated each headline's believability, credibility and truthfulness.
As they worked through the exercise, the participants spent more time and showed significantly more activity in their frontal cortices -- the brain area associated with arousal, memory access and consciousness -- when headlines supported their beliefs but were flagged as false.
These reactions of discomfort indicated cognitive dissonance when headlines supporting their beliefs were marked as untrue.
But this dissonance was not enough to make participants change their minds. They overwhelmingly said that headlines conforming with their pre-existing beliefs were true, regardless of whether they were flagged as potentially fake.
The flag did not change their initial response to the headline, even if it did make them pause a moment longer and study it a bit more carefully.
Political affiliation made no difference in their ability to determine what was true or false.
The experiment showed that social media users are highly subject to confirmation bias, the unintentional tendency to gravitate toward and process information that is consistent with existing beliefs, she said.
This can result in decision-making that ignores information that is inconsistent with those beliefs.

41 minutes ago
Trump administration unveils 'patriotic education' initiative as new priority for federal education grants

2 hours ago
Tucson City Council in Arizona to open with ancient Hindu prayers

3 hours ago
Did Deepika Padukone exit 'Kalki 2898 AD' due to commitment issues?

3 hours ago
Tannishtha Chatterjee wishes ‘incredible woman’ Shabana Azmi on 75th b’day

3 hours ago
Ananya Panday flaunts bronzed glow post her Maldivian holiday

3 hours ago
Divya Dutta to Shabana Azmi: You are supremely precious in my life

3 hours ago
Kerala a bridge between India and Europe: CM Vijayan on blue economy conclave

3 hours ago
Bengal student murder: Protest erupts at Birbhum school, headmaster thrashed

3 hours ago
India-US tariff stalemate likely to be resolved in 8-10 weeks: Chief Economic Advisor

3 hours ago
Rahul Gandhi claims 'systemic' vote deletions in Congress booths, sidesteps question on legal course

3 hours ago
'Yoga instructor sexually assaulted me during Thailand competition': Teenager tells police

3 hours ago
Nilgiris Forest Department in TN clamps down on tourism inside private tea estates

3 hours ago
KITE distributes robotics kits to Lakshadweep schools