Mumbai, April 15
Attempting to pick holes in
the prosecution case against Bollywood actor Salman Khan in the 2002
road accident, the actor's counsel on Wednesday said after the accident,
the actor's blood samples were tampered with and his medical
examination was done in just five minutes.
Defence counsel
Shrikant Shivade argued before Additional Sessions Judge D.W. Deshpande
that the first primary evidence, the medical case paper, showed that
Salman was brought before Dr Shashikant Pawar of Sir J.J. Hospital at
2.25 p.m. and discharged at 2.30 p.m. on September 28, 2002.
"According
to the exhibits, his BP was checked which was 138/88, pulse was checked
which was 88 per minute, eyes checked for dilation, abdomen was
examined which was soft, and as far as smell (of alcohol) was concerned,
it was kept blank... This means there was no alcohol, and also he was
made to walk straight. Do you think all this is possible in five
minutes," Shivade asked.
He also contended that Salman's blood
samples collected at the government-run Sir J.J. Hospital were tampered
with at the behest of police with the intention to nail the accused
(Salman), hinting at a police-medico nexus.
Shivade questioned
the logic of the Bandra police station of not collecting the blood
samples at the neighbourhood civic-run Bhabha Hospital in Bandra and
instead sending him to the government-run hospital in Byculla, south
Mumbai.
"It is mentioned that blood collection facility was not
available at the Bhabha Hospital... is that possible? It is a reputed
hospital. It has an operation theatre and an ICU... Do you mean to say
that syringes and blood sample collection is not present there?" Shivade
argued.
Dwelling upon the cross-examination of medico Pawar who
examined Salman and collected the blood sample, Shivade said Maharashtra
Medical Code rules were not followed, including taking the consent of
the accused and other aspects.
"His consent was not taken... in
an invasive procedure... do you want to follow the procedure laid down
here, or in Namibia and Ethopia?" he demanded.
Citing another
important factor, Shivade said the blood samples were collected on
September 28, 2002 afternoon, and sent for examination after two days
and actually tested on October 1.
"The evidence is silent on how
it was stored, where it was kept and under whose custody? The vials used
were stored in his (the doctor's) chamber... Many patients come and
go... there are chances of contamination," he pointed out.
He
added that the blood samples were collected without (Salman's) consent,
gloves were not used, and the samples were sealed by a ward boy,
preservative sodium chloride was not used though an anti-coagulant was
used.
"When preservative is not used, it leads of fermentation,
which would show presence of alcohol even if there is no alcohol in the
blood... Absolutely no precautions were taken," Shivade said.
The
defence lawyer's arguments came in the ongoing re-trial of the
September 28, 2002 accident case involving Salman when his Toyota Land
Cruiser rammed into a bakery in Bandra west, killing one pavement
dweller and injuring four others.
The defence arguments will continue on Thursday.
