America
Baltimore makes 'thug' the new four-letter word
By
By Arun Kumar
Washington, May 1
As Baltimore City. just over
60 km from the American capital, erupted into riots and violence over
the police-custody death of a black man, it also ignited a debate over
the Hindi word 'thug' after President Barack Obama used it to describe
the rioters.
So did Baltimore Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake and
lo and behold it had been uttered 625 times on TV on Monday, according
to regressing.deadspin.com citing iQ Media that tracks closed captions
in all US markets.
"The word 'thug' has been used so many times
by the same sort of people about the same sort of thing that it's no
longer even accurate to call it code - it's really more of a shorthand,"
it said.
Webster's Dictionary defines "thug" as "a brutal
ruffian or assassin," but the website suggested "It means a black guy
who makes white folks a little more uncomfortable than they prefer."
"Of course it's not the right word, to call our children 'thugs,'" Baltimore City Councilman Carl Stokes told CNN.
"These
are children who have been set aside, marginalized, who have not been
engaged by us. No, we don't have to call them thugs."
"Just call them n-----s. Just call them n-----s," he said. "No, we don't have to call them by names such as that."
The
Rev Jamal Bryant drew the same comparison on CNN. The President and the
mayor are wrong, he said. "These are not thugs, these are upset and
frustrated children."
'Thugs' is the 21st century word for the
n-word, said Bryant. "And it is repulsive and it is offensive to every
person who is a parent trying to raise children interpreting what's
taking place in this hour."
"'Thugs.' 'Thug.' The derision
here-dismissive, indignant, wilfully unsympathetic-is implied in the
sound of the word itself," said the Atlantic magazine tracing "The
History of 'Thug'" to colonial India.
"Even if you hadn't heard
the word before, even if you had no idea what it meant, you would
probably guess that it is an epithet," it said.
"In Baltimore
over the past few days, the term has been flung about by commenters both
professional and non-, mostly as a way of delegitimizing the people who
are doing the protesting and rioting," said the Atlantic.
"To dismiss someone as a 'thug' is also to dismiss his or her claims to outrage," it said.
So
much so Rawlings-Blake had to clarify her comments on 'thugs'. "When
you speak out of frustration and anger, one can say things in a way that
you don't mean," she wrote on Twitter Wednesday.
"That night we
saw misguided young people who need to be held accountable, but who also
need support. And my comments then didn't convey that," she added.
According
to CNN, National Football League (NFL) player Richard Sherman has
previously called the term "the accepted way of calling somebody the
n-word nowadays."
"Etymology experts have traced the word thug to
the Hindi word meaning a cheat or a swindler," said the Newsweek
outlining a brief history of the word 'Thug' prompted by Baltimore.
"Colonial accounts speak of groups of Thugs who practiced Thuggee and would rob and kill travellers," the magazine noted.
"Some
accounts describe these Thugs as belonging to a religious cult that
worshipped the goddess of death and destruction and killed in order to
please her."
"Such accounts made their way into Western culture during British colonization and through anthropological writings," it noted.
(Arun Kumar can be contacted at [email protected])